This Critical Fantasy Weapon Tier List guide ranks all the weapons currently available in Critical Fantasy (Roblox), with detailed explanations for each placement. Whether you’re trying to pick your starter weapon or optimize your late-game build, this breakdown will help you make the best choice.
Critical Fantasy Weapon Tier List Guide
D Tier – Completely Outclassed
Wooden Sword / Wooden Staff / Wooden Bow
These are your starter weapons, and quite frankly, they’re not worth holding onto.
Why they’re here: They’re just weaker versions of the tier 2 weapons (Divine Sword, etc.) with lower stats and no unique advantages.
Use until: You get anything better, ideally Divine Sword or Copper Sword early on.
C Tier – Functional but Flawed
Silver Whisper (Bow)
Why it’s here: Damage is decent if you build up arrows before attacking, but it makes farming slower and riskier.
Downsides: Arrows spawn slowly, and their orbs don’t give you upward momentum, so you’re more vulnerable to damage.
Ultimate: Can deal solid damage, but it misses too often to be reliable.
Verdict: Better than the Wooden Bow but still a sub-optimal choice overall.
B Tier – Reliable Midgame Choices
Divine Sword (Tier 2)
How it works: Deals increasing damage with consecutive orb hits.
Why it’s here: A straightforward weapon with good early-game damage, but it’s eventually outclassed by higher-tier swords.
Drop Source: Crimson Slime boss has a high drop rate for this weapon.
Verdict: Solid choice until you can upgrade to Tier 5 combo swords or other high-end gear.
A Tier – High Potential with Some Downsides
Tier 5 Bow
Why it’s here: High base attack stat, but still carries all the limitations of bow-based classes — mainly slow farming and vulnerable gameplay.
Verdict: Stronger than Silver Whisper but not good enough to compete with the best melee or magic weapons.
S Tier – Best of the Best
Rootbound Spire (Magic)
Why it’s here: Currently the highest-tier magic weapon in the game.
Class: Belongs to the Flow class, which got nerfed, but magic is still extremely viable.
Verdict: Incredible damage potential. Still one of the top picks despite nerfs.
Crescendo (Crit Class)
Why it’s here: One of the highest DPS weapons in the game thanks to its critical damage and echoing passive.
Playstyle: Doesn’t require comboing — just collect orbs and let the passive handle the rest.
Ultimate: Auto-tracking, consistent, and high-damage with crit potential.
Verdict: Arguably the strongest weapon for pure burst potential. RNG-dependent but incredibly rewarding.
Tier 5 – Winter Howl (Combo Sword)
Why it’s here: Offers more consistency than Crescendo, but requires more mechanical skill due to its combo-heavy playstyle.
Ultimate: Surprisingly weak — hard to land and underwhelming in most cases.
Verdict: Second-best weapon in the game. If you can master it, the raw output is deadly.
As the game updates and new weapons are added or rebalanced, these rankings may shift. But for now, this list reflects the strongest and weakest tools at your disposal.